Tito's Pizza St Mary's – Authentic, Flavor-Packed Pizza & Wings in St. Marys, ON

The service is really good. They prepared my meat lovers pizza order very quick. Thanks to Surya for all the quickness. The taste is also really good and shows how a meat lovers should be from my pizza. Cleanliness is good too and they prepare it with all good hearts. No reason to reject this place and try it out. Simply tasty and superb. Thanks team

i order from here at least once a week - its always very consistent, and well-made pizza. the (unbreaded) wings are also juicy and cooked very well, with good sauce flavours. overall very good prices and consistently good food make me a frequent customer

Visited this local store in town on Friday. It was incredibly busy, so a bit of patience was needed while waiting for our order. The staff were juggling two to three phone calls a minute—it’s clear they have a tough job. Despite the rush, the person at the front was very kind and helpful with my order. Since I chose to wait inside, they prioritized my pizza, and it turned out exactly how I expected. Great experience overall—highly recommend this place! Plus, the prices are cheaper compared to other stores. Kudos to the team!

Tito’s Pizza – St. Marys’ Unexpected Champion It almost feels wild to say this, but here it is: this might be the best chain pizza location I’ve ever been to. And I’ve been back more than 10 times, so I’m not saying that lightly. The pizza? Consistently spectacular—crispy where it should be, gooey cheese, fresh toppings, and packed with flavour. And the crust? Oh man—the crust is brushed with this magical garlic sauce that somehow makes you look forward to eating every last bite. No crusts left behind. Ever. But the real surprise? The wings. I can’t stop ordering them. Some of the best wings I’ve had in the area —hands down. Perfectly sauced, juicy, and seriously addictive. I’ll go back for the wings alone—and you absolutely should too. The crew at this Tito’s is something else. Fast, efficient, and you can tell everyone is giving it 1000%. It’s rare to see that kind of hustle and pride in a chain location, and it makes all the difference. This spot is a total gem. I’ll always go back to this Tito’s—and once you try it, you probably will too.

Definitely recommend stopping by if you're craving a solid slice or a full Slice. I’ll be back to try more of the menu!

Same great pizza, different locations! We're big fans of Tito's pizza, and anytime we pass by a town that has one, we make sure to grab a slice (or 8)!